Pizzelles - My Incredible Recipes (2024)

Pizzelles are light, sweet, and the perfect crunch to an Italian cookie. If you are looking for the perfect pizzelle recipe you just found it. Learn how easy it is to make this holiday anise pizzelle cookie recipe for you and your family. This cookie recipe that does use a pizzelle iron to make the stunning decorated cookies.

Dust with a little powdered sugar, place on a platter or cookie tin and you have a breathtaking holiday Italian cookie.

Make sure to check out my classic thumbprint cookies or these shortbread cookie bites. Both are great holiday-friendly desserts as well.

What Are Pizzelles?

Pizzelles are very thin and light Italian waffle-style cookies. These cookies have a very elegant design as you use a pizzelle iron for creating the cookies.

These cookies are made and served often around the holidays or for special occasions. You will find the process, flavor, and such can vary depending on where you live.

Reasons To Make These Italian Pizzelles

• These are delicious anise-flavored cookies. Now, you can always alter the flavor to create a different flavor of the cookie. Vanilla, almond, etc.
• These are traditional Italian cookie that is light, and delicate and are a holiday tradition in many households.
• Homemade cookies that are baked from scratch and taste just like grandma used to make.
• Customize these cookies from design to flavor.

Ingredients You Will Need

Flour – All-purpose flour is what you will want for the base of these cookies.

Baking Powder – This is needed for the texture of the cookies.

Salt – The salt is so important when you bake. It is going to balance all the flavors in the cookie recipe.

Eggs – Large eggs are what I used. I do recommend that you use room temperature eggs as they will incorporate into the other ingredients better.

Sugar – Granulated sugar is the sweetener of the cookies.

Anise – This is the classic flavor of these cookies. But you can also use other flavors if you want.

Oil – Canola oil or vegetable oil both work for this cookie recipe. You want an oil that is minimal in flavor.

Tips for Making Pizzelle Cookies

Preheat Iron

Preheat the pizzelle iron so that when you place the batter on the iron it is nice and hot and begins cooking right away. A cold iron can cause the cookies to be overcooked or undercooked.

Texture of Batter

You want the pizzelle batter to have a thicker texture like a cake batter. If it is too thin the cookies will be too crispy.

Greasing The Iron

Make sure to use a cooking spray to create a non-stick surface for the cookie batter. I recommend using as it is going to prevent the cookies from sticking in the iron.

Don’t Add Too Much Batter To the Iron

You will find that if you add too much batter to the iron it will run over like a waffle maker. So make sure to pour in the center of the iron, and do a smaller portion.

Cooking Time

Depending on the griddle iron will depend on how fast or slow the cookies take to make. Just try to time them right once you find the perfect doneness so they all get a great consistency.

Cooling Cookies

I recommend using a wire cooling sheet so that it going to allow the cookies to cool on both sides of the cookies. You want them to fully cool before you place them to be stored.

Practice

Just remember that it does take a bit of time to master the cookies. From the texture of the batter to the cooking time. So just make sure to know the first few might not be perfect but you will catch on quickly.

Storing

Ensure the cookies are completely cooled before you go to store the cookies. You will want to place the cookies in an airtight container and store them at room temperature.

I do recommend placing wax paper between each layer of the cookies, as they are fragile.

I have successfully frozen the cookies as well, just place them in a freezer container and freeze them for 2-3 months. Then eat straight from the freezer or thaw on the counter.

FAQs

How do I prevent pizzelle cookies from sticking to the iron?

To prevent the cookies from sticking, I recommend using a lightly greased iron. Make sure to spray or brush with oil before you add the batter to the iron.

On what occasions are pizzelle cookies commonly served at?

Christmas celebrations, weddings, Easter feasts, and more family-friendly gatherings. You will find these cookies are great for every single occasion throughout the year.

Can I shape pizzelle cookies?

While the cookies are still warm you are more than welcome to shape the cookies. You can roll the cookies and fill them with a filling like a cream or whipped cream. Then add items like mini chocolate chips, nuts, etc.

Can I double the recipe?

Yes, go right ahead and make as many of these cookies as you would like. Just mix and cook as many as you would like. The biggest thing is ensuring the cookies get to cool completely.

More Tasty Cookie Recipes

I have a few more cookies you might want to check out before you go. I love baking and these cookies will be a hit for parties, events, and even a mid-week sweet tooth fix.

• Cherry Blossom Cookies
• Twix Cookies
• Churro Cookies