Shrimp Salad Sandwich (2023)

Published: Aug 16, 2021 · Modified: May 24, 2022 by Radwa · This post may contain affiliate links. 5 Comments

This shrimp salad sandwich combines many delightful ingredients that enhance its light, delicious and creamy flavor, perfect for a summery lunch out.

It has a velvety and buttery texture from the mixture of shrimp, mayonnaise, and butter. Plus, sandwiched between two pieces of bread, the texture of the combination also has some crustiness hints.

Also, check Cheese and Pickle Sandwich and Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich.

The dish is good for lunch and dinner since it can play as the main course due to the heavy combination of shrimp and bread.

Shrimp Salad Sandwich also has lemon juice, parsley, and seasonings like paprika and ground pepper which highlights the natural tender sweet-salty flavor of the shrimp.

This recipe will address the versatility of the shrimp and its uses. It will also provide tips on preparing the dish with a twist, along with what may help someone prepare the sandwich like a pro.

Related: Fish Finger Sandwich and Asian Sloppy Joe Sandwich.

History of Shrimp Salad

Alison Roman has written for The New York Times that shrimp salad was introduced in San Francisco, California, in the early 1900s. However, the shrimp salad in those times was named after its original creator, thus bearing the name Shrimp Louie. The recipe of this variation also mainly contains shrimp, lettuce, mayonnaise, boiled egg, or what you'd call Thousand Island Dressing.

The mentioned Thousand Island Dressing typically includes lemon juice, olive oil, paprika, and other seasonings.

Eventually, as time goes by, the recipe for Shrimp Louie got altered from one restaurant to another and from one household to the next. Along with the introduction of the sandwich, the addition of butter and yogurt is one of the alterations. The shrimp salad has a creamy texture, perfect for a sandwich; thus, it goes well with a slice or two of bread.

Check Toasted Cheese Sandwich and Mexican Chicken Tortilla Wraps.

Why Does This Recipe Work?

There are many ways one can prepare a Shrimp Salad Sandwich, but this particular recipe works better because of the following reasons:

• The whole dish is healthy and easy to make.
• The ingredients are not expensive, and you can find them in the nearest market.
• Shrimp salad sandwich is versatile to eat for lunch, dinner, or even at snack time.

Ingredients of The Recipe

• Shrimp: As the base ingredient of the recipe, shrimp will give the whole dish a sweet and salty taste. When choosing a shrimp to make the Shrimp Salad Sandwich, it is best to use shrimps already deveined and peeled, which means that the shrimps' shells and dark dorsal veins are already gone. The size of the shrimp also depends on one's likings, but it is best to buy medium size shrimps since it will suit the sandwich well.
• Butter: The rich flavor and creamy texture of butter add to the satisfaction that the shrimp salad sandwich offers.
• Seasonings: paprika, salt, and ground black pepper. No matter how many additions you add to the salad, the taste isn't the same without the traditional seasonings. Paprika, salt, and ground black pepper bring out the aroma and flavor of the dish just like what it does for the other food.
• Lemon Juice: Lemon juice does not only enhance the taste of the dish by adding sweet and savory flavor. It also gives a fresh and clean taste to the whole food.
• Parsley: It has a fresh taste perfect to complement the lemon juice for the salad mixture. It will also brighten the flavor of the shrimp salad.
• Bell Pepper: It is just another ingredient that will add color and flavor to the salad, similar to what the other seasonings provide.
• Mayonnaise: The shrimp salad will come out as dry without the creamy texture of mayonnaise. Mayonnaise is the one responsible for the more significant contribution of the cream in the dish.
• Greek Yogurt: This type of yogurt has less sweetener and thicker consistency. It will help mayonnaise provide a rich and creamy texture.
• Green Onions: Add a crunchy texture to the salad, along with a mildly sweet tone that may seem unnoticeable.
• Chopped Pickles: Top the salad with something green! Pickles have salty and sour tastes that will surely complement the other flavor in the salad.
• Hot Dog Buns: What is a sandwich without bread or buns? Hot dog buns will surely envelop the creamy goodness within its hold.

How to Make Shrimp Salad Sandwich?

• Melt the butter in a large skillet over medium-high heat.
• Place the shrimp and cook for 2 minutes or until it is not translucent (don't overcook).
• Transfer the shrimp into a mixing bowl, let it cool down for 10 minutes, then add paprika, salt, ground black pepper, chopped pickles, green onion, parsley, bell pepper, lemon juice, mayonnaise and greek yoghurt.
• Mix well until combined. Then, scoop the mixture into the hot dog buns, sprinkle some paprika on top and serve.

Top Tips for A Better Sandwich Experience!

• If you don't like soft bread, you can splatter the hot dog buns with butter and toast them in medium-low heat.
• Don't overcook the shrimps lest they become too lumpy for the sandwich.
• Let the salad cool down for 10 minutes before putting them into the hot dog buns. It will allow the flavor to sip in and won't make the buns too soft.

Some Variations

• If you have a soft spot for spicy food, adding diced red onion will give the salad a spicy tint. You may also add a pinch of cayenne pepper.
• Add smashed avocado to the salad for a creamier and sweeter version of the sandwich.

Serving Suggestions

Shrimp Salad Sandwich is suitable for almost any meal of the day. Hence, pairing it with a simple glass of orange juice is a perfect combination. Orange juice has a sweet flavor with an undertone of bitterness, perfect for the creamy and delicious taste of the sandwich.

Recipe FAQs

Recipes you may like

• Easy Shrimp Tacos
• spinach and potato salad
• Mashed Potato And Onion Pie

Best Sandwich Recipes For Summer

Recipe Card

If you like this shrimp salad sandwich recipe and want to save it for later? Add it to your favourite recipe board on Pinterest!

Follow Healthy Life Trainer onFacebook,PinterestandInstagramto keep up-to-date with all new recipes. Also, you can subscribe to myNewsletterto recipe all the latest recipes once published.